Hannah Hatch Turner Tinkham Tupper

Sally Thomas has been doing a great job raising questions about the accuracy of this profile.

We need to resolve the parent conflicts.

This footnote explains the basis for Hannah Hatch's three husbands, which is not without controversy because there is no known record of her first marriage to Japhet Turner:

HANNAH HATCH3, daughter of Samuel Hatch of Scituate, by His wife Mary2 Doty Edward1, was born on 15 or 16 February, 1681-2, and was married three times. She married, first, Japhet Turner, of Scituate, but the date of the marriage has not been found. Japhet Turner died before 23 January, 1710-11, when his inventory was ta ken, and left four children. Hannah, who married William Thomas Japhet, who married Elizabeth Morse Israel, who marr ied Abigail Holmes Elizabeth, who married John Pratt. Hannah Hatch3 Turner married, second, on 9 July, 1719 , Ebenezer Tinkham4 Ebenezer3, Mary2 Brown, Peter1, o f Middleorough, Mass., as his second wife. Ebenezer Tinkham4 died before 7 November, 1726, when Shubael Tinkham4 , his broth er, was appointed administrator. Hannah Hatch3 Turner Tinkham married, third, on 23 De c e mber, 1729, Capt. Ichabod Tupper, of Middleborough, who died in 1748, leaving children by a former wife. Hannah Hatch3 Turner Tinkham Tupper, widow of Capt . Ichabod Tupper, died 13 April, 1771, in her 91st year , a ccording to the record on her gravestone in the Nemasket Cemetery, at Middleborough. The day of the month is doubtful, as one date was written over the other. 98Hannah Hatchs Three Husbands No record of the marriage of Hannah Hatch3 to Japhet Turner has been found, and she was called Hannah Tinkham, in her father s will, made 13 June, 1728but the widow Ha nna h T upper, in her own will, dated 26 August, 1766, mentions my daughter Elizabeth Pratt, also my ten grandsons and my fifteen grandaughters, naming each of them. As these twenty-five grandchildren of widow Hannah Tupper can be proved to Have been the children of Japhet and H annah Turner s four children, Hannah Thomas, Japhet Turner, Israel Turner and Elizabeth Pratt, it is evident that the first Japhet Turners widow was the Hannah Turner who marrie d Ebenezer Tinkham and Capt. Ichabod Tupper. Ebenezer Tinkham4 Ebenezer3, Mary2 Brown, Peter1 was the only Tinkham who had a wife Hannah in 1728, when Samuel Hatch mentioned a daughter Hannah Tinkham in his will, and we have shown that Ebenezer married, for his second wife, Japhet Turners widow Hannah. Moreover the widow Hannah Tupper's age at death agrees closely with the birth date of Hannah Hatch3. It is evident, therefore, that Samuel Hatch's daughter Hannah and the widow Hannah Tupper were one and the same person. We here present exhaustive abstracts of all records, and original documents in the files, found in the Plymouth County, Mass., Registry of Probate, relating to the est ates of Ja phet Turner, Ichabod Tupper and widow Hannah Tupper. These abstracts have been made at the expense of Mrs . A . V . Heely, of Plainfield, N. J., who is a descendant of Hannah Turner5 Japhet4, Hannah Hatch3, Mary2 Doty , Edward1 , who married James Le Baron. The proper reference, to the record, or the original document in the files, is noted with each abstract. A descendant of Pilgrim Edward Doty. !BIRTH MB&D , MB&D, Vol.1,pg 429 !BIRTH MF, Brown , MF, Brown, pg.23 !DEATH MB&D , MB&D, Vol.1,pg 429 !DEATH MF, Brown , MF, Brown, pg.23

http://www.e-familytree.net/F249/F249144.htm

This article and other sources on Doty Family genealogy sites claim that Hannah Hatch is the daughter of Mary Doty Hatch. Does anyone know a source for the link to Mary Bryant as her mother? Does everyone agree this relationship is an error that should be removed?