The age difference between Amanda and her daughter Lucy Jane Taylor is inconsistent. I have found this information on findagrave.com:
Amanda Jane Garrett Garrett: Memorial ID# 269750852
Memorial Per: Virginia Deaths & Burials Index, 1853-1917 FHL Film #2056973 - Daughter Of: William & Susan Garrett - Married James Alexander Garrett - Sept. 1854 Buckingham County, Virginia.
Take note Amanda's parents have different names as well. I'm at a standstill and not sure where to go from here. Help!
