William Carr, Gent., of Spotsylvania County - Which William Carr?

https://www.colonial-settlers-md-va.us/getperson.php?personID=I7615...

William Chiles Carr b. 1707 New Kent probate 4 November 1760 Spotsylvania
Parents; William Carr d. 1738 New Kent & NN Chiles (daughter of John Chlies & Mary Boucher),
Spouse: 1) Elizabeth Winston d. 1737
Spouse: 2) Susannah Brooks (1720-1792) m. 1740 (no parents listed);

11 children including Susannah b aft 1744 but she's not listed with a husband in 1760 or a guardian bond.

1749-1759 Spotsylvania County, Virginia Will Book B; [William Armstrong Crozier];

CARR, WILLIAM, Gentl. Spotsylvania Co., d. Aug. 2, 1760, p. Nov. 4, 1760.
Wit. A. Foster, William Ellis, John Gordon.
Ex. wife, Susannah Carr, Edward Herndon, Joseph Brock.
Leg. wife, Susannah, land bought of Thomas Ship and John Quarles;
son Thomas; son William, land in Louisa Co.,
daughter Ann Carr, land adjoining Nicholas Crenshaw;
daughter Elizabeth; daughter Phoebe;
son, Walter Chiles Carr, land in Louisa Co.,
son, Charles Brooks Carr;
daughter Agnes Brooks Carr;
son-in-law Mordacai Hord;
son, Charles Carr;
daughters Susannah, Sarah and Mary.

Codicil to the foregoing will, dated Aug. 12, 1760.

1749-1759 Spotsylvania County, Virginia Will Book B; [William Armstrong Crozier];
GUARDIANS BONDS
£3000 Susannah Carr, guard. to Charles Brooks Carr, Agnes Brooks Carr, Walter Chiles Carr, Phebe Carr, Thos. Carr, orphs. of Wm. Carr, gentl., with Anthony Foster, John Holloday and Wm. Lewis, sec. Nov. 6, 1760.

WikiTree contributors, "William Carr (abt.1680-1760)," WikiTree: The Free Family Tree, (https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Carr-414 : accessed 05 November 2024). is more or less the same; misses daughter Susannah; has notes:

Estimated birth date

The birth date is a very rough estimate, based on the assumption that he was the younger brother and born only a few years after brother Thomas. Many online genealogies give a birth date of 1707 for him, but this appears to be based solely on a baptismal record for the "William, ye Son of Thomas Carr of Bay gate" who was was baptized at Bolton-by-Bolland in Yorkshire on 16 October 1707.[3] This cannot be the same person, as the records cited in his profile establish that William's father Thomas was living in King William County, Virginia, between at least 1701-1709, not in Bay gate, Yorkshire, England.

Disputed Spouses

Some have identified various additional spouses with a LNAB of Winston. These include Elizabeth Sarah (Winston) Carr, Elizabeth (Winston) Carr, and Catherine (Winston) Carr. No sources are cited in any of these profiles and they have been detached as spouses of this William Carr.

I found this, although I cannot yet identify the original source.

https://www.familysearch.org/tree/pedigree/landscape/9SSM-WRF

On 22 February 1751, William Carr of Spotsylvania County gave to his son-in-law William Crenshaw and his beloved daughter Susanna for "good will, love and affection" 400 acres in Louisa County on the North side of the North branch of the North fork of the James River, bounded by Ambrose Joshua Smith, John Mallory JR.

Crenshaw Genealogy:

• 1. William A. Crenshaw (1725-1799) & Susannah Brook Carr (1707-1800)
  • 1. Cornelius Crenshaw
  • 2. Charles Brook Crenshaw (1749-1814) & Eunice White
  • 3. David Crenshaw (1751-) & Jane Waddy
  • 4. Nancy "Ann" Crenshaw (1756-1800) & Thomas Crenshaw
    • 1. Joel Crenshaw Jr.
    • 2. Frances Crenshaw (1800-)
  • 5. Mary Crenshaw (1762-) & John Crenshaw
  • 6. Susannah Crenshaw (1767-) & John Burnly
  • 7. Agnes "Aggy" Crenshaw (1769-) & Thomas Fretwell
  • 8. Jamima Crenshaw & William Fretwell Jr. (1736-1807)
    • 1. Crenshaw Fretwell* (-1822) & Mildred Burnley
    • 1. Crenshaw Fretwell* (-1822) & Sarah
    • 2. John Thomas Fretwell* (1773- 1837)
    • 2. John Thomas Fretwell* (1773- 1837) & Mildred "Milley" Garth (1779-1832)
    • 3. Thomas Fretwell (-1822)
    • 4. William Fretwell* (-1807) & Mildred Overton Burn
    • 4. William Fretwell* (-1807) & Vienna Kinsolving
    • 5. Susannah "Susan" Fretwell* (1777-1802) & Elijah L. or S. Garth (1772-1816)
    • 5. Susannah "Susan" Fretwell* (1777- 1802) & William Brown
  • 9. Joel Crenshaw (1776-) & Jane (Jean) Swift
  • 10. Sarah Crenshaw (1778-) & William Dickinson
  • 11. Patsy Crenshaw (1780-) & Hardin Turner