There are two Catherine Gorsuch listed as being buried in Know County Ohio on findagrave.com.
One, Catherine Ely Gorsuch is given as being born November 1810 in Northumberland County, PA and died December 05, 1852. Her husband is Jacob Gorsuch. If she was born November 1810, This person fits the data given in the profile here. However, then her mother was about 14 years of age when giving birth to her. Also on findagrave.com she is given as marrying Jacob Gorsuch in 1850 when she was 40 years of age.
The second Catherine Gorsuch listed as geing buried in Knox County Ohio was born in 1824 and died 1895. Her husband is Issac Gorsuch. Her birth date is appropiate for her mother giving birth to her in her late 20s.