Albert I von Dagsburg - Is Albert's father Hugo IX or not.

Started by Eddie Presley on Sunday, December 18, 2022
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 8 posts

The notes for Albert says "Wrong Father.... this profile is incorrect too... " but you have Hugo listed as his father. Hugo's notes (I think from MEDIEVAL LANDS" states he had two children HEINRICH and GERBERGA. Which is correct the note or the profile? If the note is correct who is his father?

Eddie Presley it looks like the link between Albert and any parents is speculative.

Even the link between Albert I and Albert II is unsupported:

https://fmg.ac/Projects/MedLands/LOTHARINGIAN%20(LOWER)%20NOBILITY....

Alex, what is the different between speculative and unsupported in this case, it's clear that there is no recording that Albert I was the father of Albert II, he could actually have been a grandfather, but were they related, more than likely since the County of Moha was at that time an allod, in fact, the landowner had the same right like a prince, and as such, Moha goes from father to son.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allod

Hi Ulf, my post wasn't a legal treatise so just read speculative and unsupported however you feel like.

Swap them even, Unsupported for parents of Albert I and Speculative for parents of Albert II is probably better semantics than what i wrote earlier.

Happy New Year!

To me when the notes for Albert says "Wrong Father.... this profile is incorrect too... " a red flag goes up. If it said speculative and unsupported then you can say the lineage may or may not be correct. A lot is posted here from "MEDIEVAL LANDS" which says 2 children not 3. I mentioned in one post that I had seen several that said parents are not known, but they have parents listed and was told to flag it with a discussion, I think this would fall under that statement.

Eddie, you can't rely on DIY links on the web, but there is another problem here.

Mathilde Albertsdtr von Egisheim

Mathilde von Moha

Can you see what?

I try not to rely on the DIY links. I know that the LDS site just puts out what is given. Rootsweb shows who loaded their tree and you can pick one and hope its right. Since this site says it is a one world tree and they have people to take care of it you would hope it would be better. I think that you have two Mathilde's (looking at the parents names) but their birth dates may be wrong along with Hugo's but I'm not seeing what you are pointing at. It list Hugo VI being born before 1074 and death in 1049 with his sons Gerold being born 954-1074, I think this could be a little better.

"...they have people to take care of it..." genealogically this is up to us, the users. Geni staff are purely responsible for maintaining the functioning of the platform.

Showing all 8 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion