John Hamilton, Resident in Glasgow - JOHN HAMILTON RESIDENT IN GLASGOW

Started by Private User on Friday, June 3, 2022
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Showing all 3 posts

At least eight pedigrees published by MyHeritage claim that John Hamilton, resident in Glasgow, was the son of James Hamilton, Earl of Abercorn, and his wife Marion Boyd, although evidence of relationship is not offered.

https://www.myheritage.com/matchingresult-34b4d7777e974a26a4dc2d679...

James Hamilton, 1st Earl of Abercorn

Marion Boyd, Countess of Abercorn

Moreover, no mention of a son named John Hamilton is made in any of the following more reliable accounts of the Earl of Abercorn and his family:

1. The Scots Peerage I: pp. 46-8. 2. Hamilton Memoirs: pp. 189-90. 3. Stirnet: Hamilton 10.

https://archive.org/details/scotspeeragefoun01pauluoft/page/48/mode...

https://archive.org/details/historicalgeneal00ande/page/189/mode/1up

https://www.stirnet.com/genie/data/british/hh4aa/hamilton10.php

In view of the foregoing, and in the absence of evidence supporting the claim being made, I propose to disconnect John Hamilton from the family tree of James Hamilton, Earl of Abercorn.

I agree. So far I have NO CLUE regarding the ancestry of my William Alexander Hamilton (1793-1866), beyond the names of his parents: James Hamilton and Abigail Moore. (Abigail survived James and later married a man named John Coburn.) I have no idea who the parents are for James or Abigail. I know my William Alexander Hamilton did live in Anson (now Union) County, NC, and that he married Sarah Griffin. I don't have any evidence that my Hamilton line has any connection to the semi-royal Hamilton line, i.e. the Abercorn OR Duke of Hamilton line. I suspect that someone wanted to link to an illustrious pedigree and made a lot of assumptions. What we need is PROOF!

Questioning a possible pedigree is different than attempting to destroy a possible pedigree on this and other internet websites for personal reasons. Destroying years of work in a few days, especially by an individual who might have a vendetta or a personal dislike for a family is, I would think, unthinkable and unacceptable. Why this was allowed, I will still question.

We all realize papers of birth records are sometimes lost or destroyed for various reasons, including, but not limited to politics, religion, peer pressure, fire, flooding, migration and war. Examples, John Hamilton (Church of Scotland) possible son of James Hamilton, 1st Earl of Abercorn (a Protestant of the Church of Scotland whose wife was Catholic and whose children were going to be converted to the Catholic faith after his death) and Alexander Hamilton Captain (Covenanter) (a Scottish Covenanter who supported the Presbyterian Church of Scotland) possible son of Sir George Hamilton of Donalong (a Catholic).

The Scottish exit from the Catholic Church of Rome occurred in 1560, Glasgow Cathedral worship, ministry, and governance changed permanently in line with Reformation principles. The Church of Scotland is the national church in Scotland now. James Hamilton IV Duke of Châtellerault and 2nd Earl of Arran eventually changed his allegiance from the Catholics to the Protestants. There were many other conflicts during this time and records were possibly lost or destroyed.

Even the family of the of the person who made the deletions on this website had ancestors who had changes in their lives after this period. The family of William Ford, Gamekeeper in Hamilton had lived in East Gordon, in Gordon parish, Berwickshire, Scotland (bordering the north boundary of England), but later moved to Hamilton, Lanarkshire, Scotland William Ford, Gamekeeper in Hamilton. And with one ancestor being buried in 1847 at the Old Parish Church, Hamilton, Lanarkshire, Scotland (of the Church of Scotland (William Ford, Gamekeeper and Forester).

The situation would likely be different if the person had at least found one little piece of new information to aid in identifying alternatives to the parents that he had eliminated.

Showing all 3 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion