Mordechai (ben Yom Tov) Jaffe Benet (Banet Yufe)

Private User

4/18/2022 at 5:46 AM

There is a serious mix up here, my wifesancestor was not R Mordechai Banet of Nikolsburg, I hope it is just a mistake in his occuoation, and not a whole tree mixup.

Private User

4/19/2022 at 4:54 PM

Rabbi Mordechai Markus Mordechai רבי מרדכי Benedict Benet

Randy Schoenberg C

4/21/2022 at 10:59 AM

Private User Can you tell us where the mistake might be? I see

1. Miriam Schreiber (Benedikt)
2. Rabbi Benzion Yosef Benedikt b. 1956
3. R' Yechiel Benedikt b. December 15, 1907; d. September 22, 1960, Bene Beraq, Israel
4. R' Eliezer Shlomo Benedikt (Banet) b. August 1, 1879, Bicske, Hungary; d. August 23, 1939, Bratislava, Bratislava Region, Slovakia
5. R' Yakov Gershon Banet (Benedikt) b. December 18, 1846, Beckov, Slovakia; d. 1924, Bicske, Bicskei, Fejér, Hungary
6. Rabbi Eliyahu Banet (Benedikt) b. 1810; d. 1895, Bytča, Žilinský kraj, Slovakia or Bicske, Fejér County, Hungary
7. R' (Moses) Mordechai Banet of Stomfa b. June 24, 1775, Obuda, Budapest, Hungary; d. November 19, 1849, Stupava, Bratislavský kraj, Slovakia, Stampfen, Stomfa
8. Rabbi Yaakov (Joachim Markus) Banet, of Stomfa b. 1747, District III., Budapest, Budapest, Budapest, Hungary; d. July 25, 1812, Alt-Ofen, Budapest, Hungary
9. R' Yochanan Banet, Dayan of Alt-Ofen (Budapest), Hungary b. circa 1727, Budapest, Hungary; d. 1779
10. R' Avraham Aberl (Eberl) Banet b. circa 1700, (Óbuda) Budapest, Hungary; d. between 1755 and 1758, Nikolsburg, Mikulov, Břeclav District, South Moravian Region, Czechia (Czech Republic)
11. Mordechai (ben Yom Tov) Jaffe Benet (Banet Yufe) b. circa 1650, South Moravia, Czech Republic; d. April 1, 1725, Jihomoravský kraj Czech Republic, Nikolsburg, Mikulov, Břeclav District, South Moravian Region, Czechia (Czech Republic)

Dotty Brown PRO

4/21/2022 at 4:48 PM

From what I've researched, if your Yochanan Banet is correct, he would have been the uncle of the famous Rabbi Mordecai Banet who was born in Csurgo in 1753 and became chief rabbi of Moravia in Nicholsburg (where he is buried. He died in 1829) Yochanan's sister was Fradel (wife of Abraham Bia, father of the 1753 Mordecai Banet). Fradel and Yochanan's father was your #10. And Abraham Aberl Banet's father would appear to be your number 11.
I don't see R. Mordecai Banet of Nikolsburg in your list.
Best, Dotty Brown (5x great granddaughter of the chief rabbi )

Private User

4/23/2022 at 10:47 AM

It seems interesting that here is another Mordechai Banet who was rabbi of Nikolsbourg... that is what it says on the profiles occupation.
So I assumed there is a mixup.
But I looked up the tree in Beer Hamoadim from Avraham Benedikt (from where the tree is taken) and this tree is right according to him.
I am trying to find where the known tree (as it used to be on geni), which has a different Avraham Abrel (by number 10) who is a descendant of the Levush, is sourced, any leads?
Avraham Benedikt apparently also changed his mind before he passed away a couple of years ago about how the tree goes, and conceded that it is the one with the Levush, which makes it all thw more important to find out its original source.

Mordechai (ben Yom Tov) Jaffe Benet (Banet Yufe) - Not Rabbi of Nikolsburg

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion