Nice & contradictory!
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Brown-30561 Phoebe Brown, the daughter of Benjamin Brown and Mary Shurtleff. She was born on 12 Jan 1732 in Canterbury. She married Joseph Butts on 6 Jan 1748 in Canterbury. She then married Matthias Button on 16 May 1753 in Canterbury.
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Brown-78689 Phoebe Brown, daughter of Benjamin and Mary, was born in Canterbury, Connecticut on 12 Jan 1735. [1] She married Samuel L Butts in 1765.[2]
Currently showing as daughter of Elisha Butts