I thought NN MacFarlane Campbell had a name

Начала Laurie Vieau (MacFarlane) пятница, 15 октября 2021
Возникла проблема на этой странице?

Участники:

Упомянутые профили:

Показаны все сообщения (18)
15.10.2021 в 3:26 после полудня

I thought she had a name? Margaret Campbell, of Ardaillour Margaret MacFarlane (Campbell) (c.1524 - c.1568) - Genealogy Genealogy for Margaret MacFarlane (Campbell) (c.1524 - c.1568) NN Campbell, of Ardaillour Laurie

Private User
17.10.2021 в 6:31 до полудня

Yup, she did have.
Margaret Campbell, of Ardaillour's profile was updated by Dean (Cowper) Pascoe. death, display name and first name
Oct 10

Dean Rowland Pascoe - how about explaining why you made those changes

2.11.2021 в 12:38 до полудня

Hi Laurie and Lois,

I changed the name as at least three of the sites I checked (e.g. the Clan MacFarlane genealogy database, and the peerage website) record Andrew MacFarlane's wife as the "unknown daughter of Dougal Campbell and Janet Graham" or do not list any information regarding Andrew's spouse (Stirnet.com).

Over to you if you want to change it back or make comment in the bio section that she may have been known as Margaret.

6.11.2021 в 12:20 после полудня

Okay, I see what you mean, I checked on clan MacFarlane genealogy and she is listed as NN. When I first came here I saw her name listed as Margaret, but on the other hand, it will be best to have this woman listed as NN until there's more information on her. Cheers

6.11.2021 в 12:30 после полудня

Dean, I found her name on Ancestry.com but before making any other changes it would be best to look for other sources as well. Cheers. https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/andrew-dubh-macfarlane-o...

Private User
6.11.2021 в 12:37 после полудня

Dean Rowland Pascoe - Thanks for giving the explanation. Had you put a comment of explanation in her Overview or created a Public Discussion from her where you gave the info, that would have been helpful. Since you didn't, this discussion was started, you gave the explanation here, and now all is good - anyone looking in future can find the explanation here.

6.11.2021 в 12:46 после полудня

I found extra information for good to be extra sure. It's an older source since it's from Rootsweb Margaret Campbell1

F, #8659, b. circa 1524
Father: Dougal Campbell of Ardaillour2 b. c 1493, d. b 10 May 1550
Mother: Janet Graham2 b. c 1495
Relationship: 10th great-grandmother of Donald James MacFarlane
Last Edited: 29 Sep 2013
Birth*: Margaret Campbell was born circa 1524 at Ardaillour, Scotland.1
Marriage*: She married Andrew "Dubh" MacFarlane 2nd Baron of Gartartan or Gartvertane, son of Walter MacFarlane 1st of Gartartan or Gartvertane and Janet Galbraith, circa 1560.1,3
Married Name: As of circa 1560,her married name was MacFarlane.1,3
Family: Andrew "Dubh" MacFarlane 2nd Baron of Gartartan or Gartvertane b. c 1524, d. b 1611

Andrew MacFarlane+1 b. c 1560, d. b Oct 1623 http://homepages.rootsweb.com/~maritime/p184.htm#i8659

Private User
6.11.2021 в 12:58 после полудня

Laurie Vieau (MacFarlane) - that is information from somebody's family tree.
A family tree should never be considered a source - people can put whatever they want in their family trees. There are probably very few that are purposely wrong, but many, many with errors. If a family tree has records attached to it, those can be helpful. The information on the tree should just be taken as a hint.

Private User
6.11.2021 в 1:03 после полудня

I was referring to Laurie's first post referring to Ancestry. But I think her second reference is also to a family tree

6.11.2021 в 1:05 после полудня

Lois, I know those names from https://www.clanmacfarlanegenealogy.info

6.11.2021 в 1:13 после полудня

Until there's concrete sources found nothing should be changed. At least there's an idea of her possible first name. Cheers

Private User
6.11.2021 в 1:19 после полудня

Laurie - your link above gets me
"Forbidden
You don't have permission to access this resource.

Additionally, a 403 Forbidden error was encountered while trying to use an ErrorDocument to handle the request."

6.11.2021 в 1:24 после полудня

Let's see if it works now with starting off with with my great grandfather
https://www.clanmacfarlanegenealogy.info/genealogy/TNGWebsite/getpe...

6.11.2021 в 1:25 после полудня

It's working for me, could it be your location. The website did have problems a few weeks ago

Private User
6.11.2021 в 1:48 после полудня

Starting with great grandfather works. Other, still error.

6.11.2021 в 2:13 после полудня

Okay I'm going to have to start on the tree and see if I can get up to my 11th great grandfather, and see what's going on.
Cheers

6.11.2021 в 2:17 после полудня

https://www.clanmacfarlanegenealogy.info/genealogy/TNGWebsite/getpe...

and his wife NN Campbell MacFarlane

https://www.clanmacfarlanegenealogy.info/genealogy/TNGWebsite/getpe...

I don't know why the malfunction, hopefully it will be corrected soon. Laurie

6.11.2021 в 2:28 после полудня

I tried to google it, and I even had trouble getting to the website, I used my bookmarks, and got through.

Показаны все сообщения (18)

Зарегистрируйтесь или войдите в систему чтобы участвовать в этом обсуждении