Sophie Green - Disconnect Sophie Green from Jacob and Sarah Green

Started by Private User on Thursday, April 2, 2020
Problem with this page?

Participants:

  • Private User
    Geni member
  • Private User
    Geni Pro

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 3 posts

I do not think that Sophie Green was the daughter of Jacob Green, {Russia} and Celia aka Sara Green, {Russia|}. Jacob and Sarah (my great grandparents) had only four children: Anna Lewy (1883-1945), Louis Aaron Green (1885-1976), Naomi Green (1892-1894) and Morris Green (1893-1993). According to the 1910 census, Jacob and Sarah were born in Russia in 1860 and married in 1880, Jacob immigrated to the US in 1890, and Sarah immigrated to the US in 1893 along with with Louis (and presumably Anna, who did not appear on this census page because she was already aged 27, married to Herman, and had a 5 year old son Archie). My grandfather Morris was born in New York and also appears on the 1910 census.

I have contacted Private User, the manager of this profile, on 7/22/2017 and again on 3/27/2020 and asked her to please link Sophie Green to her correct parents, but received no reply, so today (4/2/2020) I am asking the Curators to please disconnect this link, along with the links of Jack Green and Hyman Green. All three of these profiles were added by the same manager Private User. As further evidence that Sophie, Jack, and Hyman Green were not the children of Jacob and Sarah Green, please notice that the profiles of Sophie, Jack, and Hyman indicate that they were all born in Warsaw, Poland, while the 1910 Census confirms that Jacob and Sarah Green (and their parents and their son Louis) were born in Russia and therefore not from Poland.

1910 census: https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:33SQ-GRV6-8PZ?i=62&...

If I am understanding correctly there should be 2 families

Family 1
Jacob GREEN born 1860 and Sarah ? born 1860 - born Russia, married 1880
* Anna GREEN 1883-1945
* Louis Aaron GREEN 1885-1976
* Naomi GREEN 1892-1894
* Morris GREEN 1893-1993

Family 2
* Jacob GREEN and Sarah ? born Poland
* Jack GREEN born Poland
* Hyman GREEN born Poland

Is this correct?

I have reversed a wrong merge

Have a look and see if it is correct. Please let me know if there are any changes needed.

Leanne

Showing all 3 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion