Deacon Benjamin Parsons - Parents?

Started by Cynthia Curtis, A183502, US7875087 on Saturday, January 4, 2020
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 22 posts

Are Hugh and wife Elizabeth the correct parents?

I see William Parsons and Margaret Parsons (Hoskins) were disconnected but I am asking if this was on purpose? I am looking for

sources and not seeing them.

Thank you.

Have you reviewed the citations in the profile about? What do you think yourself (pro & con)?

I looked for sources and at the revision tab when I did not see the parents I expected and I DID FIND them IN the sources and the history so I am curious how the parents changed and changed to Curated profiles both mother and father

The latter couple is unsourced and pretty barren/sparse

Deacon Benjamin Parsons's About says:

"Benjamin Parsons was a grandson of Thomas Parsons, of Great Milton, Oxfordshire, England, who died in 1597." (2) so perhaps this is the source.

I will work on finding more and adding them. I just always look at those tabs (sources and revisions)

Not sure who "I" is but there is this:

Notes
Benjamin, an early settler of Springfield, Massachusetts, was baptized May 1, 1625 at St. Mary's Church in Beaminster, Dorset, England, son of William Parsons and Margaret Hoskins (sic: I dont think this is correct....).

So I am thinking that the About needs cleaned up now that different parents have been added and curated.

I am ok with the change in parents, just caught off guard.

I have asked before about removing sources that are in error and so this question comes up again with this profile.

There are many cases of disputed or controversial or disproved or unproven or alternate parents, many with valid citations. So its good to preserve conflicting evidence.

Im surprised you said "recent change" as i wrote the "about" in 2014 with Hugh as father.

Uploaded a source for you, its 1905.

https://www.geni.com/documents/view?doc_id=6000000117368168851&

Would be good to see if there is more recent scholarship on the family.

Erica Howton Recent change is from the revision tab

Erica Howton:

Deacon Benjamin Parsons was disconnected from his parents Wlliam Parsons and Margaret Parsons (Hoskins) by Ben M. Angel, still catching up.
Jun 27, 2019 at 3:36 AM

Private User

Which is a correction based on the profile notes written in 2014.

Thank you for those sources! It does appear to be settled. Thank you Erica Howton

Actually I dont think its settled. I'd like to see more recent sources.

Interesting Ok. What about DNA sources? Are there any comparisons? I was excited to see Hoskins simply because of the name... It is one I have seen but rarely and is why I asked the original question once I made the connection.

A research question for you and others to present on discussion.

See that parents have been revised to William Parsons of Beaminster & Margaret Parsons based on better research.

Thank you

Showing all 22 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion