Charlotte Sarolta Pewny (Stark) - "sister"

Started by Private User on Sunday, September 22, 2019
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 5 posts

"Sarolta (Charlotte) Stark" is listed here as the sister of Charlotte Sarolta Pewny (Stark), which cannot be; they also seem "both" to have the same parents. I think Sarolta as a sister is an error.

Hi K,
The source of the duplicity is due to The 1848 LSM Census, mentioning family 290 (residing in Prekazka, Liptovsky Hradok): Samu Stark (age 48, b. [Dolny] Kubin), Katti (age 43), Moses (age 21), Matyas (age 19), Jakab (age 10), Joachim (age 8), Mandel (age 5), Eduard (age 3), Lotti (age 14), Doria (age 12) & Sarlotte (age 6).
Thus there are a Lotti & Sarolta.
Hopefully, once the birth records will be examined, the mystery will be solved, but for the time being - let’s leave things the way they are.

It is not uncommon for two siblings to have the same German name, most probably with a different Hebrew name.

But the link leads to one and the same person. (It is rather uncommon, David, according to my experience, for a name like Charlotte - not uncommon for short names like Rosi, Saly, Hani, Anna etc.)

What do you mean by "But the link leads to one and the same person"? There seem to be two separate profiles for the sisters, each with a different date of birth, corresponding to the 1848 LSM census.

Showing all 5 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion