I think the confusion exists between these two profiles:
Lucelia Massie (Poindexter) 1615-1719 Lucelia Massie, {Fictional}
And
Lucelia Massie (Poindexter) 1622-1711 Lucelia Massie, {Fictional}
Somethings amiss there.
BTW, Peter Massie Peter Massie. Is my 10th GGF
It’s all bogus.
Read the https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Massie-46
I am pruning and locking accordingly, unless there’s proof offered.
“There are some accounts that Peter Massey may have married a Cecilia or Lucelia Poindexter. Peter is also said to have had a daughter named Cecilia Massie. [69], that married a Robert Anderson, who was indicated as being a vestryman at Saint Peter's [70] and from Poindexter Family Genealogy we learn that researcher Doris Gilbert has located in the Massey family records a "Cecilia Poindexter" who emigrated to Virginia about 1650. There is in the parish records a George Poindexter 1627 - 1690 and his wife Susannah Poindexter that lived in New Kent County, Virginia, USA. Susannah was buried in the St Peter's parish cemetery. At least one other family tree [71] has George and Susannah as Cecilia's parents and Peter Massey as her husband. This is an unsourced and unproved tree. It is however, proven by parish records that George and Susannah Poindexter lived at New Kent, Virginia and were members of St Peter's Church. The registry does mention a number of children born to George Poindexter. George Poindexter was a warden of St. Peter's [72] Susannah's Find a Grave profile only mentions two children: George Poindexter (1650 - 1738) and Thomas Poindexter (1675 - 1706). The records of St. Peter's do not have a Cecelia or Lucelia Poindexter listed.”
Information I'm finding is that Lucelia Pointexder married a D. Massie - no other name found for her husband on the sites that list that. She's in my ancestral line and doesn't appear to be fictional based on historical society and research for the publications she's mentioned in.
I think people have merged, in some cases, a Peter Massie with her husband D. Massie and made them into Peter David Massie.
https://books.google.com/books?id=4RCglni-o4IC&pg=PA8&lpg=P...
https://books.google.com/books?id=wa2-kNd99s4C&pg=PA280&lpg...