Marion Harvie - Marion Harvie Should be Marion Mcleod?

All the siblings need Citation except Catherine Elisabeth Macleod who is sourced.

Yehuda Rubin Do you have a reference for your entries?

Erica Howton Everything that I added is sourced from MyHeritage.

Yehuda Rubin, do you happen to remember if it was a MyHeritage tree or actual records?

From my understanding MY HERITAGE is not supposed to be a source; however it can be a "Match" opportunity. These are people's personal trees and may not be based on facts.

Perhaps Marion Harvie should be disconnected until we can get some facts? That's my suggestion.

Private User It was a tree.
private Feel free to disconnect.

Ashley can disconnect or remove the lock.

* I've not been able to find a Marion as described in THE HISTORY OF THE MACLEOD.
* Marion Harvie or Marion Macloed is also not found on http://macleodgenealogy.com/

MyHeritage can absolutely be a source, especially the record collections there. That's why we need to track down the specific source. I'll look again to see if I can find where it came from -- though certainly anyone else can help.

Ashley, I'm fine with MyHeritage.com as a source (they are a sister company to Geni.com_, but I've been told my some very militant curators that it's not a source. I find selective reasoning by other curators (not you).

I would just like to resolve how someone with the last name "Harvie" who is unmarried, gets into the family tree when there is no record in the Mcleod genealogy. With limited information (no source) it appears a candidate to be disconnected from the Mcleod tree.