Norman Macleod - Mother Janet Mcleod vs. Mary MacKenzie?

Huh. Interesting find. Can we look for additional sources?

Yes, I agree that additional sources are totally warranted here!

I’m reading the child of Janet MacLeod and Malcolm, 8th of Raasay as Alexander, not Norman.

https://archive.org/details/historyofmacleod00mack/page/373

I’ll try a screenshot on his profile.

Moved Norman Macleod as son of Mary McKenzie as per source.

Will enter Janet Macleod’s daughter Anne.

The source has “crofter’s daughter of the island.” Which Island?

Erica, Presumably it's the Isle of Raasay is located on the West Coast of Scotland near Skye given that the entry was made in THE HISTORY OF MACLEODS, THE MACLEODS OF RAASAY page.

I would love to go there!
https://www.raasay.com/

Stirnet places Anne Macleod a generation below:

Malcolm Macleod (d 1832, minister of Snizort)
m. Mary Macleod (dau of Donald Macleod of Swordale) @4@ below
A. John Macleod (d 20.01.1845, Captain, 2nd son) had issue ("several daughters")
m. Anne Nyinsis
B. Roderick Macleod (b 1794, d 1867, minister of Bracadale, Moderator of the Free Church General Assambly) had issue
m. Anne Robertson Macdonald (d 1857, dau of Robert Macdonald of Skaebost)
C. Anne Macleod
m. M. Cordonniere ("a Frenchman", later in Russia)
D. Isabella Macleod
m. John Finlayson (minisetr of Bracadale)
E.+ other issue - Malcolm (d young), Christian (d unm), Donald, Charles (d unm), 2 daughters (d young)

https://www.stirnet.com/genie/data/british/mac/macleod08.php

——-

I’m not clear if Stirnet is saying these other children belong to Mary or Janet or if they don’t know

7.+ other issue (d unm) - Roderick, Charles, Margaret (d unm?), Janet

https://www.stirnet.com/genie/data/british/mac/macleod08.php#link3 Cites:

Main source(s):
(1) For upper section : 'History of the Macleods' (Alexander Mackenzie, 1889, p371+)
(2) For lower section : 'History of the Macleods' (Alexander Mackenzie, 1889, p433+)