Different birth dates.
Elizabeth daughter of Josiah Torrey, Born on 3 May 1685 in Boston, MA.
https://mathcs.clarku.edu/~djoyce/gen/report/rr14/rr14_363.html#P10490
31814. Dea. James Torrey. Born on 3 Sep 1644 in Scituate, MA.62,52 James died in Scituate, MA in 1719.
On 29 Sep 1679 when James was 35, he second married Elizabeth Rawlins, daughter of Nathaniel Rawlins (ca 1626-23 Dec 1662) & Lydia Sylvester (8 Dec 1633-), in Scituate, MA.52 Born in Jun 1661 in Scituate, MA.52 Elizabeth died in Scituate, MA on 7 Apr 1700.52
Their children include:
48968i.
Ann Torrey (16 Sep 1680-aft 1732)
48969ii.
James Torrey (5 Apr 1682-14 May 1755)
48970iii.
William Torrey (14 Sep 1683-22 Nov 1745/6)
48971iv.
Nathaniel Torrey (29 Mar 1686-4 Apr 1753)
48972v.
David Torrey (4 Jan 1687/8-2 Jan 1770)
48973vi.
Elizabeth Torrey (7 Sep 1689-)
48974vii.
Samuel Torrey (20 May 1691-)
48975viii.
Rachel Torrey (Died young) (5 Feb 1692/3-5 Mar 1709/10)
48976ix.
Joseph Torrey (13 Sep 1694-29 Apr 1762)
48977x.
Stephen Torrey (Died soon) (2 Jun 1696-4 Oct 1697)
48978xi.
Lydia Torrey (14 Jun 1698-)
48979xii.
(Child) Torrey (Stillborn) (7 Apr 1700-)
https://mathcs.clarku.edu/~djoyce/gen/report/rr23/rr23_285.html#P13814
48973. Elizabeth Torrey. Born on 7 Sep 1689 in Scituate, MA.52 Elizabeth was baptized in the Second Church of Scituate, in 1692 52
52. Vital Records of Scituate, Massachusetts to the Year 1850, NEHGS, Boston, 1909, two volumes, http://archive.org/details/vitalrecordsofsc01newe, http://archive.org/details/vitalrecordsofsc02newe.
(Doesn’t look like she survived to marry ...)