Gerhard (Matfride) von Metz, Graf - Gerhard (Matfride), father of Uda (Voda)?

Medlands shows 4 children for Gerhard & Oda http://fmg.ac/Projects/MedLands/LOTHARINGIAN%20(UPPER)%20NOBILITY.h...

WICFRID
UDA
NN
GOTTFRIED

Note that Medlands was updated last week v4.2 Updated 30 December 2018

Valerie Ohle

I am not sure if there has been a bad merge or if the scholarly view has changed recently.

Looking at the old copies of Medlands preserved in the About of the profiles it seems that Cawley has changed the structure of this part of the tree separating Gerhard, duc de Lorraine (husband of Oda) from Gerhard, duc de Lotharingia (who's wife may have been named Hidda/Ida).

http://fmg.ac/Projects/MedLands/FRANCONIA.htm#Gerharddied910

It is most likely that curators will realign Geni to match Medlands, given some time.

OK. I'm going to make myself a note to check back on this one and see if it gets changed in the future. Like I said, I don't want to carry the wrong information over to Ancestry. Folks over there seem to be a bit lax in the "fact-checking" department way too often.

Thanks, Alex!

There is a lot of interpretation this far back in the tree, it is really history rather than genealogy.
I always revert to Medlands but they are not infallible either and this is a prime example of where they seem to have changed their mind. There are Geni members who are medieval specialists but there are also a lot of Geni members who are not, even as specialists there can be differences of opinion.

I'll remove my Curator Note. Jason Scott Wills Curates - so he'll want to do the updating. Thanks for picking it up guys.