The curator note reads
—
Curator Note from Erin Spiceland (3/6/2013):
IF she is a Flake, dates indicate she cannot be the daughter of Robert, Jr., so she must be the daughter of Robert, Sr. However, indications are good that she is not a Flake at all. There may be no Alice Flake. Locked due to frequent mistakes.
—
From what I have seen so far, that note is an accurate summary of the supporting evidence, and I see no reason to presume otherwise, except to further lock the profile to “no parents.” Until such time as parents can be better proved.
Cross referencing from another discussion, please see the links with arguments made:
https://www.geni.com/discussions/188050?msg=1253545
Profiles mentioned: