Ann Stodgill (Madison) - Ann Madison Birth/Parents

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Minor-671#Trees_on_the_Web_that_seem_... Does not list a daughter Ann for the controversial Isabella Minor.

What do you see on the husband side?

Thanks, on my original tree (the offline one), i Don't have parents listed for her. it wasn't until i was on here that i saw parents listed. The Wiki page also doesn't have parents listed for her. I'd also never seen Todd mentioned as a surname until on here and trying to research it again.

On John (her husband) the following children are listed - Catherine (Madison) Gaines, Mary Madison, Ambrose Madison, Thomas Madison, Henry Madison, Roger Todd Madison, Eleanor Mary Ann Madison
On my offline tree i have Ann Madison's husband's information as
John Sturgill II b. 1665 Essex, Virginia, British America d. 1725 Orange, Virginia, British America (i don't have his family listed either as it's a line I am just getting into).

So, could that be where Todd came from (where ever he got his middle name)? According to the Wiki Eleanor Mary Ann Madison was born in 1702, mother unknown to John Madison Jr.

This is the page on Find a Grave for Ann Stodgill (according to two marriage indexes, this is how it was spelled) -- https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/113780976/ann-sturgill

So, i think, she's (Ann) is possibly Eleanor Mary Ann, as Wikitree says she was born in 1702 and this one said she was born in 1700.. and if she is really linked to John/isabella, one of these dates would make more sense and put her around the same age as Ambrose (he's listed as a brother).

Can you add the good notes from FindaGrave to Ann’s profile and adjust her dates ?

I’m going to break the connection to the Geni parents, the evidence for them is flimsy. She’s not in his will & the other children are.

If more substantial evidence turns to support her as daughter they can be put back. But we do researchers a Mis Service by keeping her connected speculatively.

Also this note from FindaGrave

“John first shows up in 1699 when he and Argyll Blackstone both proved a Letter of Attorney according to Essex Co. records.
Argyll's daughter later married John's son.
This contradicts a long-held assumption that this John's wife was Ann Madison, the purported sister of Ambrose Madison, grandfather of Pres. James Madison. The best research on the Madison family does not support the existence of such a daughter. See more under Ambrose Madison in my database.”

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/113781042/john-sturgill