James Robert Edrop, II is on Geni with 2 wives with the same name and his children have both wives as their mother.
Wife 1 Rosetta Edrop
* father John Poad William Tindale [Convict "Guildford" 1812]
* mother Elizabeth Cruickshank (Clarke) Wybrow - Tindale, Convict “Speke” 1808
Wife 2 Rosetta Tindall
* father John Tindall, Convict "Indefatigable" 1815
* mother Lucy Tindall, [Convict "Broxbournebury" 1814]
Can anyone add any supporting information on either wife?
https://australianroyalty.net.au/individual.php?pid=I926&ged=pu...
has Rosetta TINDALE
* born 1828 to John Poad "William" TINDALE and Elizabeth CLARKE
* married 21/10/1851 Penrith to James Robert EDROP "By special license, at St. Stephen's Church, Penrith, by the Rev. B. Watson, on the 21st instant, Mr. James Edrop, junior, of Parramatta, to Rosetta, youngest daughter of John Tindale, Esq., of Penrith"
* died 1886 St Leonards - Rosetta EDROP - Father John Mother Jane
Query - death record says Jane is her mother, but her mother is listed as Elizabeth????
https://australianroyalty.net.au/individual.php?pid=I81394&ged=...
John TINDALL and Lucy COOPER are listed with only 1 child John TINDALL 1821 at Kurrajong
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Tindale-126
Rosetta TINDALE aka CLARKE
born 1828 died 1935
father John Poad TINDALE
mother Elizabeth CLARKE
spouse James EDROP
Looking on ancestry.com TREES
there are 13 trees with her parents as John Poad TINDAL and Elizabeth CLARKE
there are 0 trees with her parents as John TINDAL and Lucy COOPER
None of the trees have any source documentation for the birth date.
The death date lists her father as John and her mother as Jane.
I have uploaded a copy of her death record which lists her father as John and her mother as Jane
John Poad William Tindale [Convict "Guildford" 1812] married/had a relationship with Tempest Jane Tindale - perhaps this is the Jane mentioned (step mother rather than mother)
http://www.rdhswiki.com/page/Tindale%2C+John+%281790-1857%29
In John TINDALE convict "Guildford" will he mentions his daughter Rosetta "Rosetta Edrop the wife of James Edrop of Parramatta"