Carin Påhlsdotter Lyyra (Paldanius) - Lack of sources

Started by Alex Moes on Monday, May 21, 2018
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Showing all 24 posts
5/21/2018 at 3:52 PM

A user has contacted me today to disconnect this profile from her current parent Påvel Paldanius in order to disconnect her from the Paldinius family.

While I am the curator of this profile I am not a manager, I can make the requested change but I have no idea if it is the right thing to do.

Managers, or other interested parties, please provide some evidence or a source for this woman ever existing.

Currently the profile of her husband talks about his employment but nothing of his family, there is no useful information in the profiles of their children.

Private User
5/21/2018 at 10:50 PM

Henricus Petri Lyra passed away in the beginning of 1662 (not in 1664). In tax records his wife is mentioned as Pastoris Sahl: Hr: Henricj Enckia.

http://digi.narc.fi/digi/view.ka?kuid=12892678

In July 1663 Carin Påålsdotter singed a receipt concerning her late husbands salary.

http://digi.narc.fi/digi/view.ka?kuid=12892757

This is the only time I have seen her name mentioned.

5/22/2018 at 2:01 AM

Private User could you explain "Pastoris Sahl: Hr: Henricj Enckia." to me.

Private User
5/22/2018 at 2:37 AM

Pastor, blessed Herr Henrici's widow.

Carin Påhlsdotter Lyra (Paldanius) is both Henricus Petri Lyra's wife and mother.

Henricus Petri Lyra's father was Petrus Lyra, but his wife (or wives) is unknown.

5/22/2018 at 3:17 AM

So the only document that we really have naming Henrich's wife is the receipt signed by "Carin Påålsdotter".

I think we should merge Carin Påhlsdotter, the current mother of Henricus Petri Lyra, into his wife of the same name. It is possible that both women were named Carin Lyra and even possible that both were named Carin Påålsdotter but i don't see any evidence of this.

Further I think we should disconnect Carin Påhlsdotter from the current parent Påvel Paldanius and remove "Paldanius" from her name fields. We can leave notes in her About to explain and of course this discussion will act as a record (which is one reason why i love using Discussions).

5/22/2018 at 7:31 AM

Påvel Paldanius is my mothers grandfather in 9th generation. Please do not remove!

Påvel Paldanius
Sukupuoli: Mies
Syntynyt: noin 1600
Lähisukulaiset:
Vanhemmat: Thomas, Pappi 1575 - 1603 Laurentii Paldanius
Lapset: Carin Påhlsdotter Lyyra

with regards
Anja Danska, Tampere, Suomi, Finland

5/22/2018 at 7:37 AM

You
→ Annikki Varo (os. Markkanen)
your mother → Kusti Heikinpoika Markkanen
her father → Eeva Stiina Heikintytär Markkanen
his mother → Heikki Juhonpoika Jäppinen
her father → Margareta (Marketta) Heikintytär Lyyra
his mother → Henrik Lyyra
her father → Paavo Lyyra
his father → Heikki (Henrik) Paavonpoika Lyyra , Hauho, Finland
his father → Paavo Heikinpoika Lyyra
his father → Carin Påhlsdotter Lyyra
his mother → Påvel Paldanius
her father

with regards Anja Danska 9th granddaughter, Finland

5/22/2018 at 3:18 PM

Anja Danska
Påvel Paldanius is an empty shell of a profile built 11 years ago and never added to, with absolutely no evidence attached.
How can you know he is your mothers 9th grandfather? Unless there is proof why would you? A family tree with just names but no proof is just a list of names, there is no way to know if it is accurate or fantasy.

Private User
5/24/2018 at 5:38 AM

@Alex Moes
I agree, you can merge these two Carin Påhlsdotters.

As I wrote before Petrus Lyra's wife is unknown. Petrus Lyra is unknown too. There is no information about him e.g. in tax records. Apparently he has lived in Hauho.

District court session in 1665 give us information about brothers Martinus and Jacobus. Martinus was chaplain and Jacobus farmer.

http://digi.narc.fi/digi/view.ka?kuid=3793261

5/24/2018 at 8:53 AM

My sister is a reseacher. In Finland chuirch has good books.
with kindly regards, Anja Danska

5/24/2018 at 3:26 PM

Anja Danska, I am a good researcher and I know Finland has good church books. That is not evidence of anything.

Several users now have asked me via private messages to break this connection to the Paldanius family. Ask your sister for some records for this family to prove the structure shown on Geni, all of us would be happy to keep the connection if it was supported by actual records.

5/26/2018 at 8:51 AM

Do You research my fathers Eino Varo (1903-1958) or my Mothers Annikki Varo os. Markkanen 1907-1999 granparents?

with kindly regards Anja Danska os. Varo 1935-

5/26/2018 at 8:53 AM

Petrus Lyra has lived in Hauho and was (if I remember correct) priest in Pieksämäki, Suomi, Finland.
kindly regards Anja Danska

5/26/2018 at 8:55 AM

Påvel Paldanius
Sukupuoli: Mies
Syntynyt: noin 1600
Lähisukulaiset:
Vanhemmat: Thomas, Pappi 1575 - 1603 Laurentii Paldanius
Lapset: Carin Påhlsdotter Lyyra.

with regards Anja Danska

5/26/2018 at 9:02 AM

Paavo Heikinpoika Lyyra (o.s. Lyra)
Vahvistettu
Paavo Heikinpoika Lyyra (o.s. Lyra)
Syntymä Noin 1650
Kuolema 1719 - Pieksämäki
Isä Henricus Petri Tuntematon
Äiti Carin Påhlsdotter Lyyra (o.s. Paldanius)
Vaimo Unknown Lyra
Lapsi Heikki (Henrik) Paavonpoika Lyyra (o.s. Lyra)
Sisarukset Pekka (Petrus) Henrikinpoika Lyyra (o.s. Lyra), Christina Henriksdotter (o.s. Lyra)
with kindly regards
Anja Danska os. Varo 1935-, Helsinki, Suomi-Finland

5/26/2018 at 9:05 AM

LISÄÄ KUVA
Christina Samuelsdotter Lyra (born Paldanius)
Sukupuoli: Nainen
Syntynyt: arviolta 1588–1648
Lähisukulaiset:
Vanhemmat: Dorde (Dorothea) Johansdotter Paldanius
Puolisot: Henricus Petri Lyra
Lisännyt: Anja Danska os. Varo tänään
Ylläpitäjä: Anja Danska os. Varo
0 Vastaavuudet
Tutki tätä henkilöä
Näytä sukupuu
Muuta profiilin tietoja
Yleistiedot
Media-aineisto
Aikajana
Keskustelut
Lähteet
Muutokset
DNA
Tietoa muokkaa | historia
Kerro jotain henkilöstä Christina Samuelsdotter Lyra (born Paldanius).
Näytä kaikki
Lähisukulaiset
TekstinäkymäLisää perheenjäsen
Näkyvillä 5 henkilöä

Henricus Petri Lyra
husband

Dorde (Dorothea) Johansdotter Pa...
mother

Pekka (Petrus) Henrikinpoika Lyyra
stepson

Paavo Heikinpoika Lyyra
stepson

Christina Henriksdotter Lyra
stepdaughter

wiht kindly regards, Anja Danska

5/26/2018 at 9:07 AM

Christina Samuelsdotter Lyra (born Paldanius)
Sukupuoli: Nainen
Syntynyt: arviolta 1588–1648

Hope that You can answer to the persons that irritated You ! kindly Anja Danska

Private User
5/26/2018 at 9:36 AM

Apaprently Petrus Lyra lived in Hauho, but he was not a priest. His son Jacob was a farmer, Mårten was a priest in Hauho and Kuhmoinen and Henrik in Pieksämäki.

Sources like this tax record is needed.

http://digi.narc.fi/digi/view.ka?kuid=12435503
Dominus Henricus Petri is mentioned, wife and maid are unnamed.

5/26/2018 at 1:12 PM

What I’ve understood is that Petrus Lyra was the first priest in Lyra family. I read an assay on Lyra family and Petrus Lyra and his work as a priest is actually mentioned (according to this essay) in a book from Matts Akiander. No name of his wife is mentioned.

You can find the information (including also some assumptions) in Finnish here http://www.saunalahti.fi/arnoldus/lyra.html

I’m not that good in this as I’ve done genealogy only so little. But I understand the need for some official documents though sometimes we need also some assumptions to get further.

5/27/2018 at 12:18 PM

Carin Påhlsdotter Lyyra (Paldanius) - Lack of sources
Vastasit tähän keskusteluun

Alex Moes ©
A user has contacted me today to disconnect this profile from her current parent Påvel

Paldanius in order to disconnect her from the Paldinius family. While I am the curator of this profile I am not a manager, I can make the requested change but I have no idea if it is the right thing to do. Managers, or other interested parties, please provide some evidence or a source for this woman ever existing. Currently the profile of her husband talks about his employment b...
Påvel or Påhl is writen in finnish Paavo! - Carin, Kaarina Paavontytär Lyra, Lyyra os. Paldan, Paldanius.

with kindly regards, Anja Danska

5/27/2018 at 3:21 PM

Anja,
What this profile requires is some sources https://www.geni.com/projects/Working-with-sources/18201
From what I can understand your post https://www.geni.com/discussions/181685?msg=1219447 is a copy and paste from another website? Copying data from another website is not evidence of anything, especially if you are not going to tell us which website it is so that the rest of us can look at it for our selves.

5/28/2018 at 4:04 AM

Anja Danska <anja.danska@gmail.com>
14.01 (0 minuuttia sitten)
-> minä
Anja Danska wrote 11.5.2015:
Påhl Lyra, Suntio
Suora esivanhempi (7 sukupolvea)
Syntymä: 18. Helmi 1722 - Pieksämäki, KirkonkyläKuolema: 15. Syys 1754 - Pieksämäki. KirkonkyläVanhemmat: Hendrich Lyra ja Emerentia Josefintytär Lyra (o.s. Biörnburger)Sisarukset: Josef Henricksson, Margaretha, Henrik, Catharina (Henrikintytär), Carin ja PetrusVaimo: Anna Catharina Lyra (o.s. Closterberg)Lapset: Henrik Paavonpoika, Karin, Paulus ja Margaretha

Pieksämäen nimismies Påhl Henrikinpoika Lyra
Suora esivanhempi (9 sukupolvea)
Syntymä: 1650
Kuolema: 1719 - Pieksämäki
Poika: Hendrich

With kindly regards.
, Anja Danska

5/29/2018 at 3:35 PM

Sorry Anja, the burden of proof is on those people who wish to make the connection to supply some evidence beyond just copying what other internet trees show.

5/29/2018 at 3:36 PM

Disconnected, edited and locked.

Showing all 24 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion