Andrew Muir - The Ancestry of Andrew Muir

Private User

I have done some searching on scotlandspeople and have drawn a blank.

I'll wait for others to respond, but if no one can provide a good source for his father being Sir William Mure of Rowallan then his father's name should be changed to N.N. or unknown.

Could also MP Andrew Muir and add relationship locking.

Dear Susan,

You left the following message in the overview for Andrew Muir Andrew Muir, indweller in Glasgow

"This profile was deleted by those with an Agenda. HRH Prince Kieren de Muire has the Master lineages of Clan Muir but unfortunately other people do not want to accept the Truth..."

I am a bit confused. This profile has not been deleted. I did make some additions and corrections in order to distinguish between this man and his namesake Andrew Muir, schoolmaster in Glasgow Andrew Muir, schoolmaster in Glasgow but that is all. As far as I can tell, he is still your claimed ancestor. I would have thought that you would have been pleased that I corrected such a glaring error!

For the record. My only interest in these profiles, other than the fact that I have a particular interest in Glasgow families, is to ensure that the genealogy is correctly identified using authentic records. In order to make sure that any other Geni subscriber with an interest in this profile can follow the evidence I have used, and correct it if they have evidence that is more convincing, I have given full details in the overview, including, where possible, links to published evidence.

I have invited you to share evidence with me on a previous occasion, the Geni World tree is a collaborative effort after all, but I was disappointed when I did not receive a reply. Perhaps you would agree to share your evidence for these profiles now, since you seem to disagree with the identifications I have made (although you did not say what it was that you disagreed with), or persuade HRH Prince Kieren de Muire to share the evidence he has uncovered for his Master Lineages. For my part, I would be happy to accept correction.

Yours Sincerely,

Neil

Dear Susan,

You left the following message in the overview for Andrew Muir Andrew Muir, indweller in Glasgow

"This profile was deleted by those with an Agenda. HRH Prince Kieren de Muire has the Master lineages of Clan Muir but unfortunately other people do not want to accept the Truth..."

I am a bit confused. This profile has not been deleted. I did make some additions and corrections in order to distinguish between this man and his namesake Andrew Muir, schoolmaster in Glasgow Andrew Muir, schoolmaster in Glasgow but that is all. As far as I can tell, he is still your claimed ancestor. I would have thought that you would have been pleased that I corrected such a glaring error!

For the record. My only interest in these profiles, other than the fact that I have a particular interest in Glasgow families, is to ensure that the genealogy is correctly identified using authentic records. In order to make sure that any other Geni subscriber with an interest in this profile can follow the evidence I have used, and correct it if they have evidence that is more convincing, I have given full details in the overview, including, where possible, links to published evidence.

I have invited you to share evidence with me on a previous occasion, the Geni World tree is a collaborative effort after all, but I was disappointed when I did not receive a reply. Perhaps you would agree to share your evidence for these profiles now, since you seem to disagree with the identifications I have made (although you did not say what it was that you disagreed with), or persuade HRH Prince Kieren de Muire to share the evidence he has uncovered for his Master Lineages. For my part, I would be happy to accept correction.

Yours Sincerely,

Neil