Possible incorrect Relationships

Started by Leanne M (Volunteer Curator - Australia) 🇦🇺 on Wednesday, April 19, 2017
Problem with this page?

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 9 posts

Rosa (Reis) Auerbach born 1748 died 1821 is currently showing in geni as
daughter of
- Emanuel Mendel Weil born 1735 died 1815
- Karolina Feissel Weil (Guggenheim) born 1738 died 1810
wife of
- Maier Auerbach 1746-1834
This would mean that her father was 13 and mother was 9 when she was born.

Messages between the managers of the profiles have the following information
- Rosa is daughter of Emanuel Marx WEIL born 1710 and KIPPENHEIM

Other relationships in doubt are
- Salomon Weil born 1750 to Emanuel Mendel Weil and Karolina Feissel Weil (Guggenheim)
This would mean that his father was 14 and mother 11 when he was born

This discussion is to discuss and document the fixes.

I have reversed the following merge
https://www.geni.com/merge/view?revision_id=69295488520
which now gives
- Emanuel Mendel Weil as father of Isaac Emanuel Weil

- Emanuel Mendel Weil as born 1735 died 1815

I have reversed the following merge
https://www.geni.com/merge/view?revision_id=69295484050
which now gives
- Private as husband of Karolina Feissel Weil (Guggenheim) and father of Isaac Emanuel Weil

- Emanuel Mendel Weil

Profile Managers, could you please review these profiles and see if any other merges need to be reversed or connections disconnected.

Tagging profile managers
* Private User
* Jill Chesler
* René Pierre MEYER
* Oliver Bryk
* Richard (Rick) Gary Simon
* Georges Max Teitler
* Private User

I have reversed the following merge https://www.geni.com/merge/view?revision_id=69295489930

which gives
- Isaac Soloman Weil born 1774

- Isaac Emanuel Weil born 1768

4/19/2017 at 9:00 PM

Leanne - you use the term "Tagging profile managers." What do you mean ???

RGS

Hi Rick, just making sure that the people that manage the profiles get advised of the discussion. Geni probably already does let them know but I always like to make doubly sure that they get notified so that they can add any input if they want. Leanne

4/20/2017 at 10:24 PM

What I do is send a message from the profile to the managers, including a link to the discussion. That works, too.

The extra advantage of tagging them in, is that I can tell when someone responds if they are a profile manager (and it saves me looking them up to see their relationships to the profiles) :)

Most of the time, these discussions are over many many profiles so I would find it annoying to get lots of messages rather than just the one encompassing them all.

Another advantage is that discussions about the profile are then public and easier to go back to - than trying to find who said what about who in my emails.

Showing all 9 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion