Potential other members of the haplogroup?

Started by Bill Barnes on Wednesday, April 12, 2017
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Showing all 7 posts

One way to expand our branch is to track down other people who look like they might be in the R-BY3483 haplogroup and contact them to let them know - knowing that taking the test isn't a complete shot in the dark, that there are others out there they'd match with, might encourage more to take one of the available tests (single SNP, SNP Pack or, ideally, Big Y).

I don't have any solid close matches, just a GD 0 at 25 markers to a Swiss man, which makes some sense now I have the Big Y. So I have contacted him.

I spoke to Frank on the R1b activity feed and he said that didn't have any good matches.

So what about you others?

For example, Kightley is an interesting and, relatively, rare locational surname derive from Keighley in Yorkshire. A good working hypothesis would be that all people with that surname descend from the same male line (often an important local individual). A Family Finder and Y-37 would be enough to test this. An advantage it has is being an English surname so, unlike my Irish ancestry, you can often get 300-400 years of a paper trail worked out, which would allow you to identify 4th+ cousins that are recommended for Big Y testing.

There are some on here:
https://www.geni.com/surnames/kightley

including a few living Kightleys:
Private User
Private User
Private User

Although note the variation:
https://www.geni.com/surnames/kightly

appears to come from Knightly (although that could also be a variant):
Edward Kightly

So anyone else got any good Y-STR results and/or a sufficiently deep tree to identify distant cousins who share your male line?

Hello, BY3483 family who may be following this discussion. I do not have any suggestions for potential other members but I do want to report that my ancestor GGSeve from Norway and I are GG25 of Ramiro II el Monje, rey de Aragon. Ramiro and Ines de Poitou's daughter was Petronila Ramirez, who married Ramon Bereguer IV. I have the PDF that shows the relationship from Ramiro to me but I'm not certain how to post that to you. If you know how to do that, let me know. Thanks. Bob Hovde, Evanston, IL

That's interesting!

You can use a free file uploading service like:

http://www.zippyshare.com

Although the free ones tend to remove older files with little activity. I tend to use cloud storage, especially Dropbox.

I've not tried it with a PDF but you could try Google Docs:

https://docs.google.com/

And just o clarify, you've got no good Y-STR results either?

Frank and I don't have any good Y-STR matches - do you have better results than us? A good Y-STR match would be a great candidate for testing.

[deleted the previous message as I don't think it clarified anything!]

Bill, I've found a GD 0 at Y-DNA37 level named Tore Halstensen. His ancestors are from Voss, Norway area, the same area as my most distant ancestor and also Curtis' most distant ancestor. I've requested through an intermediary that he, Tore, consider testing at 111 level and take the Big Y. I should hear back in a few days. Thanks. - Bob

That is a great result. It might help pin down the time your ancestor arrived in Norway. If some of the Scottish matches would test Big Y, it should help close the gap from the other end.

Since the Big Y upgrade I've lost all my Big Y matches, which isn't very helpful as my Y-STR results are still not useful.

I have had better success with autosomal tests but at the moment it is still an untested hypothesis:

https://www.geni.com/discussions/156342
https://www.geni.com/discussions/172227

If right, it does suggest that there are closer Y matches out there, they just haven't tested yet.

Showing all 7 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion