Two options for ascent lines

What this boils down to is a small difference on Francis Hawley 's baptism place:
Hulley Family History = bap 16 Oct 1642 St Mary's Ecclesfield (http://www.tiger2.f2s.com/FamilyHistory/familytrees/yorkshire/01/pa...)
OR
The Hulley File = bap 16 Oct 1642 St Nicholas Bradfield (http://barlowd.tripod.com/framehulley.html)
Otherwise they agree on everything else, including that he was buried 1 Jan 1712/13 St Nicholas, Bradfield.

BUT they each give him different parents
Hulley Family History =
*Francis Halley bap 20 Jan1610/11 in St Peter & Paul Sheffield
x NN
**1 Francis Halley bap 16 Oct 1642 in St Mary's Ecclesfield
(http://www.tiger2.f2s.com/FamilyHistory/familytrees/yorkshire/01/pa...)

OR
The Hulley File =
*Francis Halley bap 12 May 1600 St Nic, Bradfield
x 19 Oct 1634 St Mary Barnsley, Dorothy Ketterwell
**1 John bap 19 Jul 1635, St Nic, Bradfield
**2 Francis Halley bap 16 Oct 1642 St Nic Bradfield
(http://barlowd.tripod.com/framehulley.html)

So far, the only confirmed document we have is for
Dorothey Halley & Frauncis Halley in England Marriages, 1538–1973
*Marriage: Oct 19 1634 Saint Mary, Barnsley, York, England
*Wife: Dorothey Ketterell
*Husband: Frauncis Halley
Indexing Project (Batch) Number: M10747-1 System Origin: England-ODM GS Film number: 98529

This doesn't prove where Frauncis was born, or even that this is the Frauncis baptised in 1642.
We also appear to have no confirmation of Dorothy Ketterwell being the mother of John & Francis born in Bradfield. It would be good to find that, otherwise she should be removed.

There is no reason to believe that the info for the Francis Halley baptised 20 Jan1610/11 in St Peter & Paul Sheffield isn't correct ie there was such a person

A document confirming whether the 16 Oct 1642 baptism place for Francis is St Mary Ecclesfield or St Nicholas Bradfield, is one of the keys we need here.

With the information we have at the moment, it seems to me to be more sensible to use the line that stays in Bradfield all the way back to the a generation. (http://barlowd.tripod.com/framehulley.html)

I am therefore ignoring the Hulley Family History ascent line that goes back to St Peter & Paul’s Church in Sheffield (http://www.tiger2.f2s.com/FamilyHistory/familytrees/yorkshire/01/pa...)
Although I am going to create geni profiles for them, in the hope that we can get documentary sources (that discounts them as the SA progenitors) attached to them too.

cf Sheffield line- not the SA line:
*a. John Halley b 1555 Sheffield bur 30 Aug 1603 St Peter & Paul's Church, Sheffield x 1 Nov 1579 St PP, Rosa Wood

**b. Francis Halley bap 27 Feb 1579/80 St PP Sheffield - bur 5 Jul 1617 St PP x 11 Feb 1609/10 St PP Ann Burley

***c. Francis Halley bap 20 Jan 1610/11 in St Peter & Paul's, Sheffield