New Evidence (Including Y-DNA) point to a different parent of Benjamin Johnson Cady. JCC Sr had at least 4 sons.
Daniel Wilson Cady 1786-1869, Joseph C Cady Jr 1794-1868, Benjamin Johnson Cady 1797-1879 and Naham Cady 1816-1889 and possibly one 'sother born 1805. JCC Sr was know to be related to Davd Cady 176x1821 and both had property in several area's of Southwest Ohio. BJC;s second son Joseph Daniel Cady was likely named for his brothers and possibly Silas Naham Cady for two others.