I can't support this parentage without further information. The Geni tree for Reynolds is based on the findings of the Reynolds Family Association, and as of 1993, they do not accept it. Is there new news?
See
http://www.reynoldsfamily.org/line26/index.php
Note: the Reynolds Family Association is considered very prestigious.
Thomas and Mary Reynolds of Virginia
by Sybil R. Taylor, © 1993
T1-3 THOMAS REYNOLDS, son of [George Reynolds George] (2) and [Thomasyn Reynolds Thomasyn (Church) Reynolds,] b 1590. He m. Mary, and settled in Isle of Wight Co. VA, with his brother Christopher. About 1637 Thomas and his family settled on the Rapidan River. Issue: Henry b ca 1624 [T1-4]; Rachel; Mary; John b 1650 [T1-18]; William b 1655 [T1-114]; Thomas [T1-313]; Cornelius; Edward b 1675 [T1-360]; and Richard [T2-403]. All of the daughters d.y.
T2-5571 Thomas Reynolds, of (1894-George), b 1590 England, m. Mary -, and settled Isle of Wight Co. VA with his brother Christopher Reynolds. Ca 1637 Thomas Reynolds and his family were settled on the Rapidan River in VA. The children are not necessarily listed in order of their birth. Issue: Henry b 1624 [T2-5572]; Rachel T2-5571a, Mary, John b 1650 [T2-5586]; William b 1655 [T2-5764]; Thomas [T2-6091]; Cornelius, Edward b 1675 [T2-6163]; and Richard [T2-6260].
RFA has not located any record to clearly support any of the above information about Thomas Reynolds. While possible, until clear and convincing evidence is found, '''RFA cannot accept that Thomas is son of George and Thomasyn Church, or the brother of Christopher of Isle of Wight.'''
There are so many records of a Thomas arriving in Virginia with no information to determine if they are one and the same or many different men. Could any of them have been born in Virginia? Were any of them returning from a trip to England?