George Hay, Judge - Conflicts regarding wives and children of George Hay (1765-1830)

It is quite apparent that @Marie Antoinette Hay (born 1790), married to @Samuel Ringgold, could not be the daughter of @Eliza K. Monroe (born 1786).
@Marie Antoinette Hay must have been born of George Hay's first wife (born earlier than 1775 or so).
I have found the following citation:
"The following is from Tyler's Quarterly, vol. VIII, No. 4:
Anthony Hay married second Elizabeth, daughter of Joseph Davenport, first town clerk of Williamsburg, and had four children:
Joseph, b July 29, 1759
George, b Dec. 15, 1765, celebrated lawyer who prosecuted Aaron Burr
Anthony b November 26, 1767 (Bruton Parish register)
Charles

George Hay [son of Anthony] married twice. First wife unknown by whom he had two children: Marie Antoinette, who married General Samuel Ringgold, US Army and [a second whose name I cannot read--LD. It looks like Fayettem.]
George Hay married secondly Elizabeth Monroe, born 1787, and had one child Hortense, who married Nicholas Lloyd Rogers, of Baltimore
Virginia, who married John Rose Key
Rebecca who married Dr. Hay of Chicago
Charles, (Henson, Old Dent p 67). Charles left one son, Walter Hay."

I have not read more of "Tyler's Quarterly", but I would appreciate any other opinion or any other resource to explain who Marie Antoinette's mother might be. Thank you in advance.

Then, we shall need cooperation of certain managers to correct this tree.

Dick Fosbury 23 Nov 2014