It appears from looking at John Teets Family tree at http://johnteets.com/index.htm?ssmain=g3/p3114.htm; That Joseph Sire Hamilton is actually supposed to be Josiah S. Hamilton same dates of birth, and Different birth parents than listed in this tree. I cannot figure out how to fix it at this point but they should be:
Benjamin Franklin Hamilton b. Nov 1848 and Victora Soutards b. Dec 5, 1846, d. Nov 2, 1941