Anthony John Davis has queried the status of Phoebe Carlow as Solomon Barnato Joel wife:
According to Stanley Jackson, a Barney Barnato biographer, Solly married Ellen (Nellie) Ridley around 1889. Was Phoebe Carlow a second marriage?
I RESPONDED: It looks like Henry Barnett - who added the profile, is long gone. If you're sure that this Phoebe doesn't belong here, just start a discussion on Solly's page - so we've logged the fact that there is no evidence to keep her; and I'll delete her. Thanks for the interest. Keep on checking through these profiles using the biography - would you like to start up a Barnato project too, perhaps?
Anthony John Davis replied: Phoebe may have been a 2nd wife, but I have found nothing in my research so far about her. I have not been looking at the Joel family in any detail, so she may have been a wife at some point.
We could start a discussion, certainly there are a number of mistakes in the Barnato tree.